Coercion and capacity to consent
نویسنده
چکیده
What does the capacity to consent to treatment entail and what factors influence it? To date, most research has focussed on individual factors that impair capacity to consent to treatment, such as intelligence, cognitive capacity and symptoms of mental illness. In this presentation, I want to explore the social and interpersonal factors that influence capacity to consent. I discuss the complexity of individual and social interactions and discuss coercion in two forms; overt coercion such as is found in mental hospitals, and relational coercion, arising from dependency needs [1].
منابع مشابه
Coercion, competence, and consent in offenders with personality disorder
Competence to consent to treatment has not previously been examined in a personality disorder cohort without comorbid mental disorder. We examined competence and coercion in 174 individuals diagnosed with severe personality disorder using two validated tools (the MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool for Treatment and the MacArthur Coercion Assessment Scale - Short Form). Competence was not cate...
متن کاملDesperation May Affect Autonomy but Not Informed Consent
Dunn and colleagues (2011) provide an interesting analysis of the ethical issues involved in deep brain stimulation (DBS) for peoplewith treatment-resistant depression (TRD). I agree with the conclusions the authors draw regarding TRD patients’ capacity to consent but would like to take up the authors’ call for greater examination of theway inwhich desperation may affect patients’ decision maki...
متن کاملIs respect for autonomy defensible?
Three main claims are made in this paper. First, it is argued that Onora O'Neill has uncovered a serious problem in the way medical ethicists have thought about both respect for autonomy and informed consent. Medical ethicists have tended to think that autonomous choices are intrinsically worthy of respect, and that informed consent procedures are the best way to respect the autonomous choices ...
متن کاملI-19: Informed Consent of Infertile Couples in Iran: Legal Controversies
s:3020:"1. Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Science, Tehran Iran 2. Department of Epidemiology and Reproductive Health, Reproductive Epidemiology Research Center, Royan Institute, ACECR, Tehran Iran Informed consent is considered the most important step in clinical interventions. According to the Beauchamp’s definition the consent is: “...an a...
متن کاملThe most plausible pro-coercion view: requiring informed agreement while penalizing non-participation in research
In '(Why) should we require consent to research?' Alan Wertheimer probes whether it is legitimate for the government to 'coerce' people into participating in biomedical research, including interventional biomedical research. In debating the rules that ought to govern participation in interventional biomedical research, we should distinguish two separate moral claims. First, interventional resea...
متن کامل